Oath of the Brotherhood

  • 2–5 players · best with 4
  • 60 min
  • ages 12+
  • Complexity: light
  • little text

No. 8 in “The best games by Vangelis Bagiartakis 🇬🇷👨”

Good for
  • Newcomers – clicks after one practice round
  • Large groups (5+) – recommended by players

A famous captain has arrived on the island, reporting plunder and treasures. He seeks a few good men to strengthen his crew, but only accepts members of the Pirate Brotherhood. Players engage in a strategic worker-placement game for 2 to 5 participants, gathering resources to complete missions and earn victory points.

Who is Oath of the Brotherhood for?

  • Two players limited possible, but not a recommended count
  • Families with kids limited ages 12+, light to learn
  • Newcomers good clicks after one practice round
  • Hobby gamers limited more of an opener or closer
  • Large groups (5+) good recommended by players
Compared with its peer group
Complexity 2.1 of 5 lighter than 55% of games we list
Playing time 60 min mid-range among games we list
Age 12+ mid-range among games we list

How it feels

  • Thinking Gut feeling
  • Together Against each other
  • Talking Quiet
  • Quick Epic
  • Laughing Marvelling
  • Luck Skill

Player-count verdicts come from the BoardGameGeek community poll; everything else is derived from complexity, age rating and mechanics. We have not tested Oath of the Brotherhood ourselves.

Games similar to Oath of the Brotherhood

You like Oath of the Brotherhood and are on the lookout for a similar game? Then we recommend the following board games:

🪜 Love Oath of the Brotherhood? Ready for more – the staircase shows three games, each a little more demanding, and what each one adds.

Oath of the Brotherhood: common questions

How many players is Oath of the Brotherhood for?
Oath of the Brotherhood plays 2 to 5. Players say it works best with 4.
Can you play Oath of the Brotherhood with two players?
It works, but players recommend a different count.
How long does a game of Oath of the Brotherhood take?
60 minutes according to the publisher. A first game with the rules explanation usually runs longer.
What age is Oath of the Brotherhood suitable for?
The publisher recommends Oath of the Brotherhood for ages 12 and up.
Is Oath of the Brotherhood hard to learn?
The community rates its complexity 2.1 out of 5 — that is light.
Is Oath of the Brotherhood language-dependent?
Hardly. There is little text on the components, and it is quickly memorised.

We like Oath of the Brotherhood so much that we recommend it in the following board game recommendation lists 2026