Smash Up: What Were We Thinking?

  • 2–4 players · best with 3
  • 45 min
  • ages 14+
  • Complexity: light
  • text-heavy

No. 9 in “The best games of the Smash Up series”

Good for
  • Two players – recommended by players
  • Newcomers – clicks after one practice round
  • Hobby gamers – enough depth for repeat plays
Less suited to
  • Families with kids – ages 14+, light to learn
  • Large groups (5+) – 4 players at most

Never be fooled by a sweet face; behind that cuddly smile lurks a beating! If you survive the onslaught of teddy bears, you'll encounter rockstars, grandmas, and explorers – seriously, what were we thinking? This expansion brings back the wild randomness of the early days of the game, allowing you to pit zombie rockstars against explorer dinosaurs or time-traveling grandmas against teddy bear vampires. Your wildest dreams can finally come true!

Who is Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? for?

  • Two players good recommended by players
  • Families with kids not really ages 14+, light to learn
  • Newcomers good clicks after one practice round
  • Hobby gamers good enough depth for repeat plays
  • Large groups (5+) not really 4 players at most
Compared with its peer group
Complexity 2.3 of 5 heavier than 79% of card games
Playing time 45 min longer than 56% of card games
Age 14+ playable later than 85% of card games

How it feels

  • Thinking Gut feeling
  • Together Against each other
  • Talking Quiet
  • Quick Epic
  • Laughing Marvelling
  • Luck Skill

Player-count verdicts come from the BoardGameGeek community poll; everything else is derived from complexity, age rating and mechanics. We have not tested Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? ourselves.

Games similar to Smash Up: What Were We Thinking?

You like Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? and are on the lookout for a similar game? Then we recommend the following board games:

🪜 Love Smash Up: What Were We Thinking?? Ready for more – the staircase shows three games, each a little more demanding, and what each one adds.

Smash Up: What Were We Thinking?: common questions

How many players is Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? for?
Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? plays 2 to 4. Players say it works best with 3.
Can you play Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? with two players?
Yes. Players recommend it with two.
How long does a game of Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? take?
45 minutes according to the publisher. A first game with the rules explanation usually runs longer.
What age is Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? suitable for?
The publisher recommends Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? for ages 14 and up.
Is Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? hard to learn?
The community rates its complexity 2.3 out of 5 — that is light.
Is Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? language-dependent?
Yes. The components are text-heavy — pick an edition in your language.

We like Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? so much that we recommend it in the following board game recommendation lists 2026