Who Should We Eat?

  • 4–10 players · best with 6
  • 30 min
  • ages 14+
  • Complexity: light
  • little text
Good for
  • Large groups (5+) – the best count, players say
  • Newcomers – clicks after one practice round
Less suited to
  • Two players – needs at least 4 players
  • Families with kids – ages 14+, light to learn

After a mysterious plane crash, players are part of a group of survivors stranded on a deserted island. They must pool their resources to build a raft large enough for escape, but food is scarce, and desperation grows. As survival instincts kick in, the struggle leads to a chilling choice: resorting to cannibalism, while an unsettling supernatural presence looms, ensuring they never leave the island.

Who is Who Should We Eat? for?

  • Two players not really needs at least 4 players
  • Families with kids not really ages 14+, light to learn
  • Newcomers good clicks after one practice round
  • Hobby gamers limited more of an opener or closer
  • Large groups (5+) very good the best count, players say
Compared with its peer group
Complexity 1.7 of 5 heavier than 84% of party games
Playing time 30 min mid-range among party games
Age 14+ playable later than 73% of party games

How it feels

  • Thinking Gut feeling
  • Together Against each other
  • Talking Quiet
  • Quick Epic
  • Laughing Marvelling
  • Luck Skill

Player-count verdicts come from the BoardGameGeek community poll; everything else is derived from complexity, age rating and mechanics. We have not tested Who Should We Eat? ourselves.

Games similar to Who Should We Eat?

You like Who Should We Eat? and are on the lookout for a similar game? Then we recommend the following board games:

🪜 Love Who Should We Eat?? Ready for more – the staircase shows three games, each a little more demanding, and what each one adds.

Who Should We Eat?: common questions

How many players is Who Should We Eat? for?
Who Should We Eat? plays 4 to 10. Players say it works best with 6.
Can you play Who Should We Eat? with two players?
No — needs at least 4 players.
How long does a game of Who Should We Eat? take?
30 minutes according to the publisher. A first game with the rules explanation usually runs longer.
What age is Who Should We Eat? suitable for?
The publisher recommends Who Should We Eat? for ages 14 and up.
Is Who Should We Eat? hard to learn?
The community rates its complexity 1.7 out of 5 — that is light.
Is Who Should We Eat? language-dependent?
Hardly. There is little text on the components, and it is quickly memorised.

We like Who Should We Eat? so much that we recommend it in the following board game recommendation lists 2026